Difference between revisions of "Talk:Locations"

From The Shartak Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
(response to Lint re: the Western Islet/Island)
Line 17: Line 17:
 
==Island/Islet off the west coast==
 
==Island/Islet off the west coast==
 
*Two pages regarding the above body of land have been created - [[La Islet Bonobo]] and [[Shark Island]]. I do not wish to unduly clutter the main page, but would like to link to them. Does anyone have suggestions for what would be appropriate? [[User:Anothertwilight|Anothertwilight]] 02:39, 3 May 2006 (BST)
 
*Two pages regarding the above body of land have been created - [[La Islet Bonobo]] and [[Shark Island]]. I do not wish to unduly clutter the main page, but would like to link to them. Does anyone have suggestions for what would be appropriate? [[User:Anothertwilight|Anothertwilight]] 02:39, 3 May 2006 (BST)
**Oh I didn't realize that there was another article. Quite a difficult situation since there is no "official" term and no easy way to refer to that location. Perhaps we should create a new article titled something nondescript like '''The Large Western Islet'''. Then merging and redirecting the two existing articles to that place. It will be a mostly NPOV, but also have two sections for POV-comments by RE and DCC. --[[User:Lint|Lint]] 02:52, 3 May 2006 (BST)
+
**Oh I didn't realize that there was another article. Quite a difficult situation since there is no "official" term and no easy way to refer to that location. Perhaps we should create a new article titled something nondescript like '''The Large Western <del>Islet</del> <add>Island</add>'''. Then merging and redirecting the two existing articles to that place. It will be a mostly NPOV, but also have two sections for POV-comments by RE and DCC. --[[User:Lint|Lint]] 02:52, 3 May 2006 (BST)
 
***I created the 2nd ([[Shark Island]]) in response to the first and have been deliberately non-NPOV; that being the heart of this all-in-good-fun conflict. It does, however, conflict with the otherwise wonderfully neutral wiki and hence my concern over where and how to link to either/both. I am tempted to push/promote the RE version as the 'official' one; the classic resolution to discoverer/naming disputes is to appeal to an authority to recognise their version; but this may be one of those 'thin end of the wedge' situations, where the wiki becomes cast as a kind of referee or judge for in-game contests. [[User:Anothertwilight|Anothertwilight]] 03:03, 3 May 2006 (BST)
 
***I created the 2nd ([[Shark Island]]) in response to the first and have been deliberately non-NPOV; that being the heart of this all-in-good-fun conflict. It does, however, conflict with the otherwise wonderfully neutral wiki and hence my concern over where and how to link to either/both. I am tempted to push/promote the RE version as the 'official' one; the classic resolution to discoverer/naming disputes is to appeal to an authority to recognise their version; but this may be one of those 'thin end of the wedge' situations, where the wiki becomes cast as a kind of referee or judge for in-game contests. [[User:Anothertwilight|Anothertwilight]] 03:03, 3 May 2006 (BST)

Revision as of 03:30, 3 May 2006

Huts

  • In Durham there's a hut that's unremarkable on the outside, but inside thte description is "All around are crates labelled with things like "Warning: Ammunition", some of which have been prised open and emptied of their contents", and it was easy to find rifles and bullets. Are there any other huts like this around Shartak? --Grigoriy 16:13, 4 March 2006 (GMT)
    • There is something similar in Wiksik -- inside one hut there is a trading post with a vigilant watchdog inside. --Berry 05:58, 5 March 2006 (GMT)
    • There is a trading post in raktam as well, i wasted like 30AP and came up with nothing searching so I think the trading posts are quitle different from weapon/item caches when it comes down to search rates, I haven't checked all of the huts in raktam so there may still be a weapon building there(i could see all outsider villages having a weapon cache to find ammo as it appears that darts are easier to find then bullets in the jungle). The map of shartak is almost filled in, maybe we could add a pic of the ingame map with village locations sometime soon, I can point out raktam easily! -- Daylan 11:06, 9 March 2006 (GMT)

Trees

  • The lists of trees are growing a bit silly now, and it occurs to me (although only after having noted the locations of several myself), that the data, as well as being a touch overwhelming, isnt actually particularly useful. Does anyone have any suggestions for how to make it a bit more navigable, as having an easy way to locate the nearest tree would be very useful. -- Less Than Lethal
    • I'm noticing a couple carved trees with messages warning about poisonous bushes or tasty mangos, but there are no such plants in the square. If the vegetation is dying and growing, perhaps it is not worth recording the specific locations of the berry bushes and fruit trees? --Lint 00:39, 24 April 2006 (BST)

Coordinates

  • Would it be possible to keep the village specifics (various hut coordinates, etc.) just on the individual village pages? We can keep the shaman coordinates, though.

    I'm considering a template box for the villages which would list (village_name), (village_shaman), (village_shamanxy), (village_armouryxy), (village_clinicxy), (village_trader), (village_traderxy). Any suggestions are welcome. --Lint 08:58, 27 March 2006 (BST)
    • Done. --Lint 00:39, 24 April 2006 (BST)

Mountain path

Island/Islet off the west coast

  • Two pages regarding the above body of land have been created - La Islet Bonobo and Shark Island. I do not wish to unduly clutter the main page, but would like to link to them. Does anyone have suggestions for what would be appropriate? Anothertwilight 02:39, 3 May 2006 (BST)
    • Oh I didn't realize that there was another article. Quite a difficult situation since there is no "official" term and no easy way to refer to that location. Perhaps we should create a new article titled something nondescript like The Large Western Islet <add>Island</add>. Then merging and redirecting the two existing articles to that place. It will be a mostly NPOV, but also have two sections for POV-comments by RE and DCC. --Lint 02:52, 3 May 2006 (BST)
      • I created the 2nd (Shark Island) in response to the first and have been deliberately non-NPOV; that being the heart of this all-in-good-fun conflict. It does, however, conflict with the otherwise wonderfully neutral wiki and hence my concern over where and how to link to either/both. I am tempted to push/promote the RE version as the 'official' one; the classic resolution to discoverer/naming disputes is to appeal to an authority to recognise their version; but this may be one of those 'thin end of the wedge' situations, where the wiki becomes cast as a kind of referee or judge for in-game contests. Anothertwilight 03:03, 3 May 2006 (BST)